.44-40 Winchester handguns, rifles and ammo
Everything in .44-40 Winchester in our online store. Pick it up at the store in Anderson. Shipping is coming soon.
Filter and sort
21 items
-
Magtech 4440C Cowboy Action 44-40 Win 200gr Lead Flat Nose 50 Per Box/20 Case
.44-40 Winchester
$59.08 Add to cart -
Horn Cowboy 44-40 205GR 20/10
.44-40 Winchester
$30.74 Add to cart -
HSM Ammunition 44-40 Winchester 200GR HL RNFP 50-Round Box 10 Boxes PER Case
.44-40 Winchester
$47.65 Add to cart -
Magtech 4440A Range/Training 44-40 Win 200gr Lead Flat Nose 50 Per Box/20 Case
.44-40 Winchester
$59.08 Add to cart -
Magtech 4440B Cowboy Action 44-40 Win 225gr Lead Flat Nose 50 Per Box/20 Case
.44-40 Winchester
$59.08 Add to cart -
Winchester 1873 Short Rifle 44-40 20″ 13-Round
.44-40 Winchester · Lever action · 13
$1,871.98 Add to cart -
Henry Repeating Arms H11 Original Henry 44-40 BL/Wood
.44-40 Winchester · Lever action · 13
$2,665.41 Add to cart -
Grizzly Ammo GC4440 44-40 Win 200gr Round Nose Flat Point 50 Per Box/10 Case
.44-40 Winchester
$86.13 Add to cart -
Winchester 1873 DLX Sporter 44-40 24″ 14-Round
.44-40 Winchester · Lever action · 14
$1,973.43 Add to cart -
Winchester 1873 Short 44-40 BL/Wood 20″
.44-40 Winchester · Lever action · 10 + 1
$1,397.51 Add to cart -
Winchester 1892 Carbine 44-40 20″ 10-Round
.44-40 Winchester · Lever action · 10
$1,172.76 Add to cart -
Taylors & Company 550296 1860 Brass Engraved 44-40 Win 13+1 24.25″ Blued Octagon Barrel, Brass Engraved/ Brass Receiver, Walnut/ Synthetic Stock, Right Hand
.44-40 Winchester · Lever action · 13 + 1
$2,231.59 Add to cart -
Henry Repeating Arms H11 Original Henry Iron 44-40
.44-40 Winchester · Lever action · 13
$2,983.56 Add to cart -
Winchester 1892 Deluxe Takedown Rifle 44-40 Win 11rd Capacity 24″ Barrel Walnut
.44-40 Winchester · Lever action · 11
$2,371.43 Add to cart -
Henry H11 Orginal Carbine 44-40 20.5″
.44-40 Winchester · Lever action · 10 + 1
$2,660.72 Add to cart -
Winchester 1892 Large Loop Carbine 44-40 20″ 10R
.44-40 Winchester · Lever action · 10
$1,372.53 Add to cart -
Winchester Repeating Arms 534202140 Model 1873 Short Rifle Full Size 44-40 Win 10+1 20″ Brushed Polish Blued Steel Barrel, Color Case Hardened Steel Receiver, Grade III/IV Walnut Straight Grip Stock
.44-40 Winchester · Lever action · 10
$1,722.15 Add to cart -
Taylors & Company 550652 Top Break Schofield 44-40 Win Caliber with 7″ Barrel, 6rd Capacity Cylinder, Overall Blued Engraved Finish Steel & Walnut Grip
.44-40 Winchester · Break Action · 6
$3,945.04 Add to cart -
Winchester 1892 Short Rifle 44-40 20″ 10-Round
.44-40 Winchester · Lever action · 10
Out of stock. Call to ask about it.
$1,173.07 See details -
New Original Henry Silver Deluxe Engraved Edition .44-40 WCF 13-Round 24.5" Barrel H011SD
.44-40 Winchester · Lever action · 13
Out of stock. Call to ask about it.
$4,024.88 See details -
Taylor’s & Company 1873 Cattleman 44-40 BL/Wood 18″
.44-40 Winchester · Single Action · 6
Out of stock. Call to ask about it.
$1,028.36 See details
Good to know
Google reviews
4.8 out of 5 from 189 Google reviews
Rating as of October 2026
As always great gun buying experience. The best shop in the greater area.
Great environment, knowledgeable staff and great inventory!
Literally one of my new happy places! It’s so amazing!
These guys are great! I’ve been shopping at Circle Star for years. If you want to work with down to earth and friendly guys with good prices, this is the place for you.
When it comes to customer service, Circle Star goes above and beyond. I have been investing in firearms, ammo, and equipment with this shop for years… and will continue to do so.
One of the best Firearm places I have been. Everyone is super nice and the owners rock. …
Great service, good atmosphere and the sales people are very professional. Good prices and selection as well. Worth the short drive out of town.
This is the best and most reasonable gun store I have ever been to. They are the nicest guys you will ever meet. … They will treat everyone the same whether you look like you could buy the store or barely afford a gun.
Give us a call
Talk to the guys at the store. We're open Monday to Saturday 9 AM to 6 PM and Sunday 10 AM to 5 PM.